“My husband and I ate Chris and Erin’s appetizers and main courses and were blown away at how fresh and delicious their dishes were. Would Highly recommended them for any private dinner or catering event. ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐”
— Kelly A
“Absolutely loved their shop, Erin, Christian and their employees. I started at their little shop in West Sayville and loved American Cheese Eatery by the Sayville train station. Loved the cheeses, all of the food, and their company. I have such fond memories and have gifted many with their skill and expertise. They are deeply missed in town and we will follow where they lead.”
— Pamela K
“The positive fun food vibe of American Cheese continues through Chefs Lennon. They brought an intimate dining experience to our home, allowing us to entertain a group of friends with a personalized menu. The food was creative and delicious, prepared fresh and specialized for our guests. The presentation was amazing too. So many great options. It was the best dinner party we have hosted and we cannot wait to do it again.”
— Lily G.
“The positive fun food vibe of American Cheese continues through Chefs Lennon. They brought an intimate dining experience to our home, allowing us to entertain a group of friends with a personalized menu. The food was creative and delicious, prepared fresh and specialized for our guests. The presentation was amazing too. So many great options. It was the best dinner party we have hosted and we cannot wait to do it again.”
— Lily G.
“My husband and I are in love with Chefs Lennon & their food! They hosted our wedding years ago at their American Cheese restaurant (it was more than we dreamed it would be!) and we have followed them around since. Their food is always outstanding and their service and vibe is always warm and welcoming. ”
— J & K
“I can’t say enough about the wonderful dishes that Christian and Erin make. We have enjoyed so many it is hard to remember them all. The St. Patrick’s Day menu comes to mind, and the marinated steak was superb. The cheese boards were a work of art. We love all of their creations… we are never disappointed!”
— Mary N.
“Christian and Erin make the most delicious food. It goes without saying that the cheeses and charcuterie boards are phenomenal. But our favorite was the bbq creations. The rubs and sauces they make are incredible. The lobster Mac and cheese is to die for. Their pairing of wines completes the meal. And to top it off the homemade desserts are delicious. We have dined with them more times than we can count, By far our favorite place.”
— D.S
“We met Erin and Christian so many years ago and have followed them from their shop in West Sayville to their wonderful eatery in Sayville. We absolutely loved our date nights at American Cheese. There was never a shortage of delicious plates on the menu. They always took pride in the quality of their ingredients and the inventiveness of their offerings. We are excited to hear of their new adventure and can’t wait to see them!!! Big love from team mojo!!! ”
— M&J
“Greetings! I just wanted to thank you all for giving us such an amazing dining experience! The impeccable attention to detail- the care taken to ensure that the pairings brought out that came out went perfectly with every dish- the food itself- succulent!! (I don’t use the word succulent lightly!) And I can’t even begin to say that each item was better than the last— and I thought the first course blew me away! Erin and Christian- your service and hospitality truly made a gourmet experience feel like a home cooked meal served with love and warmth; and rivaled any restaurant I have ever been to, both here in the states and abroad. Thank you thank you and thank you again! Can not WAIT for the next event!!”
